E22 · Release versus readiness
Synthetic practice, not company performance.
One decision
Which missing gate prevents pilot?
Run the exact query
SELECT * FROM plan_gates ORDER BY gate_id;
Download SQL · Result CSV · Metabase saved question
Chart and reading
All gate states are unverified; name the evidence and accountable role.
Challenge your recommendation
Does a well-written test count as a passed test?
Guardrails: All proposed gates unverified; no actual product release performed.
Next evidence: Actual test results, support readiness, approval and rollback drill.
PRD sections: 1, 12, 17. Open proposed PRD
Your spoken decision
State one takeaway, one caveat and one action in 30 seconds. Then stop.
Connect this finding
What this chart helps decide · Follow the connected decision · Canonical metric definitions
Optional model answer — try your own first
E22 · Release versus readiness
Decision: Which missing gate prevents pilot?
Readout: All gate states are unverified; name the evidence and accountable role.
Actual query output (synthetic), first rows:
| gate_id | requirement_id | owner_role | test | state | source_id |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| G1 | FR1 | Engineering | duplicate request returns one task and one debit | unverified | PLAN |
| G2 | FR2 | Domain reviewer | number and terminology critical cases pass | unverified | PLAN |
| G3 | FR3 | Engineering | edit invalidates prior approval | unverified | PLAN |
Model spoken answer: The specification is ready for review, but a pilot needs real acceptance evidence and owner approval.
Caveat/counterargument: Does a well-written test count as a passed test? All proposed gates unverified; no actual product release performed.
Next evidence: Actual test results, support readiness, approval and rollback drill.
Deliberately left out: A launch claim based on artifact completion.